Wednesday, May 28, 2025

"Revolution 1"

I listened to The Beatles last week and noticed that in the lines "We all wanna change the world" (the second instance) and "You say you'll change the constitution; well, you know" in "Revolution 1," the words "world" and "constitution" are sung with melismas (I think they're B G# F# E and A B A E C# B A, respectively), giving a sense of this "chang[ing]."

Years ago, I noted the corresponding melisma'd "world" in "Revolution" (sung to the notes C# G# F#), but I referenced that version again and found that "constitution" is sung with a melisma there, too (B C# B F# C# D# C# B, I think).

Friday, May 23, 2025

"All My Loving"

I recently listened to a compilation album of Buddy Holly and noticed the phrase "all your lovin'" in "That'll Be the Day" ("Well, you give me all your lovin' and your turtle-dovin' / All your hugs and kisses and your money, too").  Of course, this is very similar to the title phrase in "All My Loving."  In the immediate context, the sentiment in both songs is basically the same, too, just inverted, even structurally:  instead of "You give me all your lovin'," it's "All my lovin' I will send to you."

The Beatles were certainly familiar with "That'll Be the Day" (as the Quarry Men, they recorded a version of it in 1958), so this resemblance seems to be an indication of Holly's influence.

Friday, May 16, 2025

The Beatles (The White Album)

I was thinking about The Beatles (The White Album) recently and had a couple realizations about it.  In the liner notes of the two copies I have (a 2009 remaster and the smaller version of the 50th anniversary edition with just the two discs of the album and the Esher demos), the album's contrast with Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band is discussed to some degree.  In the 50th anniversary edition liner notes, John Lennon is quoted:  "The double album was a complete reversal from Sgt. Pepper."  Paul McCartney is more specific: "On Sgt. Pepper we had more orchestral stuff than we'd ever used before so it was more of a production.  But this time we didn't really want to go overboard on that and we've tried to play more like a band."  This musical shift seems to have carried over to the album covers, too.  The liner notes in the 2009 remaster explain that "Any expectations of a cover to rival the vivid art work of Sgt. Pepper or Magical Mystery Tour were immediately overturned.  The outside of the sleeve was completely white with the only lettering consisting of 'The Beatles' embossed on the front and also printed on the spine with the catalogue number."

In more ways than one, even the titles indicate the opposing qualities of the two albums.  The most obvious difference is the length:  "The Beatles" (even called a "minimalist title" in the 50th anniversary edition liner notes) is much shorter than "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band."  (Note that Lennon and McCartney both abbreviate it to just "Sgt. Pepper" in the quotes above.)  More significantly, though, the eponymous nature of the title "The Beatles" demonstrates an authenticity instead of the artifice involved in pretending to be Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band.