Wednesday, August 28, 2024

"Your Mother Should Know"

I was thinking about "Your Mother Should Know" recently, and I realized that the clauses "Let's all get up" and "Lift up your hearts" are sung to ascending melodies (spanning an octave:  E A C E), musically giving a sense of the meanings (although the second is more metaphorical).

Thursday, July 11, 2024

"Till There Was You"

I listened to With the Beatles yester-day and noticed a small feature in "Till There Was You."  In the line "There was love all around," the phrase "all around" is sung to notes of all different pitches (A Bb C), giving a sense of that breadth.

Sunday, May 12, 2024

"Doctor Robert"

"Day or night" in the line "Day or night, he'll be there any time at all, Doctor Robert" in "Doctor Robert" is a temporal merism.

To some degree, the structure of the song even evinces the statement "he'll be there any time at all" since the name "Doctor Robert" (or occasionally "Bob Robert") appears multiple times throughout each verse (at the end of both of the first two lines, in the middle of the verse, and at the end), suggesting a sort of ubiquity.

Saturday, May 11, 2024

"Eleanor Rigby"

The repeated line "I look at all the lonely people" in "Eleanor Rigby" is sung to a phrase something like:


Admittedly, I'm not super confident about the last two notes in each part.

The phrase "all the lonely people" is sung to pitches spanning more than an octave (A down to G and F# down to E), and this breadth provides a musical sense of that "all."  That there's a second vocal part here (in contrast to the single vocal in the verses) also gives a sense of that multitude.

Friday, May 10, 2024

"Taxman"

I listened to Revolver yester-day and noticed a few small features.  Even before I started listening to the album, I realized that the inclusion of the "one two three four" count-off in "Taxman" has a sort of double meaning in light of the subject of the song:  the musicians are counting the beats, but the taxman is counting money.

Wednesday, May 8, 2024

"Penny Lane"

Lately, I've been listening to the McCartney: A Life in Lyrics podcast.  Yester-day, I listened to the episode on "Penny Lane" and noticed a small feature in the song:  the line "It's a clean machine" exhibits internal rhyme, and this provides a sense of that orderliness.

Thursday, March 28, 2024

"Yer Blues"

A few years ago, I noted a temporal merism (morning and evening) in the lines "In the morning wanna die / In the evening wanna die" in "Yer Blues" (that's how they're formatted in the liner notes).  I was thinking about the song again this morning, and I realized that the repeated "wanna die" at the end of the lines is an instance of epistrophe and that, furthermore, since there are two rhetorical devices here, their effect is compounded, resulting in a greater emphasis.

Sunday, March 3, 2024

"Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds"

I was thinking about "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" yester-day, specifically how the choruses (the repeated title line) are sung in a higher register than the verses, and I realized that to some degree, this higher register provides a sense of being up "in the sky."

Tuesday, February 20, 2024

"Blackbird"

Yester-day, I finished reading the introduction to 1964: Eyes of the Storm.  Near the end, there's a quotation from "Blackbird," and I noticed an ambiguity in the line "You were only waiting for this moment to arise."  I don't know the proper grammatical terms necessary to explain this ambiguity precisely, but the main difference is whether it's "you" that's arising (where the arrival of "this moment" is a sort of prerequisite) or it's "this moment" that's arising (where "this moment to arise" is the direct object of the verb "waiting for").  Comparison with the later line "You were only waiting for this moment to be free," which has the same structure, suggests the former, but I think the latter is also grammatically viable.

Wednesday, February 14, 2024

"From Me to You"

I've been reading Paul McCartney's 1964: Eyes of the Storm, although I'm still only in the introduction.  Yester-day, I read a part that quoted the bridge in "From Me to You":
I got arms that long to hold you
And keep you by my side
I got lips that long to kiss you
And keep you satisfied, ooh
(That's my transcription.)

I think that reading this rather than hearing it made me realize that it's somewhat similar to Buddy Holly's "You've Got Love" (credited to Johnny Wilson, Roy Orbison, and Norman Petty).  Much of Holly's song is just a list of body parts, including arms and lips, and what they can do:  "You got two lips that look so fine," "You got two arms that you could use / To make me lose my blues," and "You got two eyes so you can see / Your love was meant for me."

The narrator in Holly's song is talking to his lover where the narrator in the Beatles' song is talking about himself, but the structure is the same:  "You/I got [body part] that...."

While the Beatles have listed Holly as an influence and there's definitely a similarity here, I'm not certain that this is an instance of the Beatles' drawing from his song.

---

Thursday, January 18, 2024

"Within You Without You"

I was thinking about "Within You Without You" yester-day, specifically the melody to which the first line is sung.  It's something like:


The lyric here is "We were talking about the space between us all."  The beginning and ending of the phrase are conjunct, but there are larger intervals (mostly fourths) in the middle, as if to illustrate that "space."

Wednesday, January 17, 2024

"Drive My Car"

I was thinking about "Drive My Car" this morning, and I realized that under the line "But you can do something in between," the drums start lending some emphasis to the off-beats, something like:


This change in the rhythm is especially conspicuous since the cowbell, which had been playing on each downbeat, drops out.

I may be making too much of this, but this emphasis on the off-beats sort of complements the "in between" in the lyric above.