Thursday, January 26, 2017

"You Can't Do That"

Backdated, archival post

[link to original on tumblr]

---&---

I got the Live at the Hollywood Bowl album for Christmas, and I finally listened to it to-day.  I discovered something about "You Can't Do That" that should have been obvious when I listened to A Hard Day's Night every week a couple years ago:  the "down"s in the lines "I'm gonna let you down" and "I think I let you down" have descending melismas.  I referenced the studio version and found that each "down" in "I'm gonna let you down" is sung to the phrase C Bb G, but the "down" in "I think I let you down" is just C Bb.  However, in both instances, there's a musical representation of the "down-ness."