Showing posts with label If I Fell. Show all posts
Showing posts with label If I Fell. Show all posts

Monday, October 25, 2021

"If I Fell"

I listened to the second disc of On Air - Live at the BBC, Vol. 2 to-day and noticed a small feature in "If I Fell" that's also present in the studio version.  Throughout the song, Lennon and McCartney are singing alternatively in unison and in harmony.  At the end of the line "When she learns we are two," they break from unison singing to harmony (on "two," Lennon sings a C; McCartney an E).  This musical break mirrors the fracture in the lyric itself.  That Lennon's C is an accidental (the song is in D major) highlights this break.

Thursday, March 19, 2015

"If I Fell"

Backdated, archival post

[link to original on tumblr]

---&---

Listening to A Hard Day's Night last week, I found an interesting connection between "If I Fell" and "Anna (Go to Him)" from Please Please Me: both have the same grammatical error.

"If I Fell" has the line "You / Would love me more than her," and "Anna (Go to Him)" has "You say he loves you more than me."  Both of these are comparisons, but the second element in each comparison is in the accusative case where it should be in the nominative, so "You / Would love me more than she [loved me]" and "You say he loves you more than I [love you]."

"Anna (Go to Him)" is one of the songs in the Beatles catalogue that they didn't write (it was written by Arthur Alexander), and while I'm not sure if there's any real connection between "If I Fell" and "Anna (Go to Him)" (I'm fairly certain I've run into this same error in other songs), I still thought it interesting that they mess up in the same way.

Tuesday, March 10, 2015

A Hard Day's Night

Backdated, archival post

[link to original on tumblr]

---&---

While listening to A Hard Day's Night, I found a few things that sort of illustrate the Beatles' progress, specifically things that make a distinction between A Hard Day's Night and their previous work.  A Hard Day's Night is particularly important in this regard as it's the first Beatles album that consists entirely of material that the Beatles wrote themselves.

While watching the A Hard Day's Night movie, I found two things in "I'm Happy Just to Dance with You" that illustrate this difference.  One of the verses starts with "I don't wanna kiss or hold your hand," which seems to make a distinction between the outlook presented in this song and the Beatles' earlier "I Want to Hold Your Hand."  An-other verse starts with "I don't need to hug or hold you tight," which - along with its structural parallelism with "I don't wanna kiss or hold your hand" - presents the same idea, contrasting "I'm Happy Just to Dance with You" and "Hold Me Tight" from With the Beatles.

While listening to A Hard Day's Night last Thursday, I found an-other instance of this type of distinction.  In "If I Fell," the lines "Love was more / Than just holding hands" also act to sort of over-write the sentiment in "I Want to Hold Your Hand."

With those phrases, the Beatles seem to be marking their new material as more advanced than their previous and placing distance between their current and past work.